A belief · not a fact · critically examined
Home › Articles
Articles
All background articles on the concept of gender identity: the critique, the research and the history — examined critically.
Conversion Act: identity as a legal premise and the consequences
The Conversion Practices Act elevates gender identity to a legal presupposition. That clashes with developmental psychology and proportionality.
Zhou Brain Research (1995): BSTc and the problems
The Zhou study (1995) on BSTc volume is often cited as evidence for "trans-brains". The methodological problems are significant.
Yogyakarta Principles (2006, 2017): legal rollout
The Yogyakarta Principles are not a treaty but an NGO document from 2006. They are used to incorporate self-identification into international policy.
WPATH SOC: from SOC1 (1979) to SOC8 (2022)
WPATH SOC went from a cautious protocol (1979) to an activist document without an evidence base (2022). WPATH Files (2024) show the editorial process.
WPATH Files (2024): lobbying and conflicts of interest
The Environmental Progress WPATH Files (2024) show that WPATH suppressed systematic reviews and was guided by activism and industry.
What is gender identity? Definition and problematization
Gender identity is not a biological fact but an ideological belief: without a marker, without a test, without proof. Definition and direct deconstruction.
Criticism of the Dutch Protocol (VUmc/Cohen-Kettenis)
The Dutch Protocol (Cohen-Kettenis, De Vries) forms the basis of global affirmative care. The methodological criticism is fundamental.
Virginia Prince, crossdressing and the term "transgender"
Virginia Prince (1912-2009) popularized transgender in the 1970s as a crossdresser, not as a surgically transitioned transsexual.
Irrefutable — therefore not science
A claim that nothing can disprove is not science but belief. 'Gender identity' is therefore not a fact — but a foundation for irreversible interventions.
Tavistock Closure GUIDE — Bell v. Tavistock + Cass
The Tavistock Gender Clinic (GIDS) was closed in 2024 following the Bell v. Tavistock case and the Cass report on dysfunctional care.
Social constructionism: arguments and limits
Social constructionism on gender: arguments, limits, and internal contradictions. Not everything socially shaped is therefore real.
Sex versus gender: a blurred distinction
Sex and gender were once distinct; now they are deliberately confused in policy. Analysis of the conceptual problem.
Self-report as the sole source
Gender identity relies solely on self-reporting. Methodologically, that is the weakest form of evidence.
SBU report Sweden and Karolinska policy
The SBU Report (2022) and the Karolinska Decision (2021) made Sweden the first country to break with the affirmative model.
Robert Stoller a "core gender identity" (1968)
In 1968, Robert Stoller postulated an immutable core gender identity. A psychoanalytic hypothesis without empirical confirmation.
Desistance: 60-90% of children desert
Classical research (Zucker, Steensma) shows that 60 to 90 percent of children with gender dysphoria lose it during puberty.
Regret figures and methodological problems
The often-cited 1-2% regret figures are based on methodologically weak studies with massive dropouts and short follow-up.
Queer theory: academic anchoring since 1990
Queer theory emerged within humanities faculties starting in 1990 as an activist academic movement. It is not an empirical discipline.
Publication bias and scientific problems in the field
The field of gender medicine is plagued by serious publication bias, retracted papers, suppressed data, and intimidation of critics. A pattern.
Performative speech act: Butler analyzes
Butler's "I declare myself" creates no biology. The performative act of speech as word magic — and an internal contradiction of activism.
Origin of the concept of gender identity
Gender identity did not arise from discovery but from ideology: Stoller 1968, Money's fraudulent Reimer case, and the growth into dogma. Genesis mapped out.
Ontology of identity: what "identity" is philosophically
Gender identity confuses numerical, qualitative, and narrative identity — and demands legal consequences from a mere self-narrative.
Norwegian guideline: UKOM report and UAGM (2023)
The Norwegian UKOM report (2023) classifies puberty blockers and hormones in minors as experimental treatment; a revised guideline followed.
No measurable marker for gender identity
There is no measurable biological marker for gender identity. Hormones, brain scans, and genes yield nothing.
No genetic marker for gender identity
GWAS research has found no genetic marker for gender identity. The heritability claim is unproven.
No brain marker for gender identity
Brain research provides no consistent marker for gender identity. The Zhou study is methodologically untenable.
NICE evidence review (2020) on puberty blockers
The NICE evidence review (2020) concluded that the evidence for puberty blockers in gender dysphoria is of very low quality.
Natural kind: is gender a natural kind?
Gender is not a natural kind à la Kripke/Putnam. Woman is a biological species; gender identity an empty collection.
Gender identity as a metaphysical claim
Gender identity is a metaphysical claim — a secular soul without marker or proof. Creed sold as science.
Magnus Hirschfeld and the Berlin Institute (1919)
Hirschfeld founded the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft in 1919 and coined Transsexualismus. First medical interventions and problematic legacy.
Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria (Littman 2018)
Lisa Littman's research (2018) describes Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria in adolescents — a pattern of sudden dysphoria caused by social influence.
Language analysis: what "gender" actually means
Etymologically, "gender" simply means "kind". From a philosophy of language perspective, the current extension to inner essence is untenable.
Judith Butler and "Gender Trouble" (1990)
In 1990, Judith Butler postulated gender as performativity. A philosophical construct from Gender Trouble, not a scientific discovery.
John Money: Gender as Learned and the Reimer Case
John Money introduced gender identity in 1964. His infamous David/Brenda Reimer experiment ended in tragedy and refuted his theory.
ICD evolution: from F64.0 to HA60 (ICD-11, 2019)
ICD-11 (2019) relocated transsexualism out of psychiatry. HA60 Gender Incongruence is a depathologization without empirical substantiation.
Harry Benjamin: Benjamin Scale and first transgender care
Harry Benjamin published The Transsexual Phenomenon and the Benjamin Scale in 1966. He laid the foundation for current medical transgender care.
Foucault, power, discourse and sexuality
Foucault analyzed sexuality as historical discourse and a mechanism of power. His work provided the philosophical building blocks for queer theory.
Feminist critique of gender identity
Gender-critical feminism defends women as a biological class. Stock, Joyce, and Lawford-Smith on identity-as-replacement.
Evidence-based objection to affirmative care
The scientific standard for gender-affirmative care is low to very low. Systematic reviews indicate this.
European rollout: EU guidelines and variation between countries
Europe broadly provided transgender care from 2010. Since 2020, Sweden, Finland, Norway, and the UK have been returning to more cautious practices.
Essentialism versus constructionism: a contradiction
Trans-ideology aims for both constructionism and essentialism. Incoherent — but rhetorically effective. The doctrine is shooting itself in the foot.
Dutch rollout: VUmc protocol and international influence
The Dutch VUmc protocol (Cohen-Kettenis, 1990s) became the international standard. Now, the small cohort and weak evidence are under fire.
DSM evolution: from GID (1980) to Gender Dysphoria (2013)
The DSM shifted from Gender Identity Disorder (1980) to Gender Dysphoria (2013). Not due to evidence, but due to activist pressure.
Spread since 2010: social media explosion and ROGD
From 2010, trans identifications among adolescent girls exploded. Tumblr, Reddit, and TikTok drove Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria.
Rollout from 2000: pediatric rollout
From 2000, transgender care shifted to children via the Dutch Protocol. Puberty blockers were used routinely without an evidence base.
Spread from 1990: first clinical practice
From 1990, transgender care spread from a few centers. A handful of adult patients, limited follow-up, weak evidence.
Detransition research (Vandenbussche, Littman, Boyd)
Scientific research into detransition (Vandenbussche, Littman 2021, Boyd 2022) shows a growing group that regrets transition.
Denial of reality: boundary of self-naming
Self-identification has limits — Otherkin, transabled, trans-racial, age-transition as reductio. Not everything that is felt is true.
Danish policy on youth gender care (2023)
Denmark tightened the policy in 2023: hormonal treatment for young people with gender dysphoria only after thorough psychiatric evaluation.
COHERE Directive Finland (2020)
The Finnish COHERE guideline (2020) states that psychotherapy should be the first-line treatment for juvenile gender dysphoria.
Circular reasoning in gender identity
Gender identity is circular reasoning: "I feel X, therefore I am X" — not science but a creed. The claim is its own proof.
Chromosomes and gametes: sex in biology
In mammals, the SRY gene on the Y chromosome determines gamete development. Sex follows from the reproductive role.
Cass Review on puberty blockers
What the Cass Review concludes regarding puberty blockers (Lupron, Triptorelin) in children: no evidence of psychological benefit.
Cass Review: Hilary Cass's NHS report (2024)
The Cass Review (NHS, April 2024) concludes that the evidence for gender-affirmative care in children is strikingly weak. Overview.
Cass Review: comorbidity and mental health
The Cass Review documents how autism, ADHD, depression, and trauma remain structurally undertreated in gender dysphoric youth.
Cass Review on cross-sex hormones
What the Cass Review says about cross-sex hormones (estrogen, testosterone) in adolescents: quality of evidence very low.
Blanchard typology: two routes to transsexuality
Ray Blanchard's typology (1989) distinguishes two separate routes to male transsexuality — empirically well-supported.
Biological sex: the gamete definition
Biological sex is defined by reproductive role: small or large gamete. Binary, observable, immutable.
Being versus feeling: distinguishing fact and feeling
Feeling is not a fact. Anorexia patients feel fat and are thin — with gender, that same category error is enforced as truth.
Autogynephilia: paraphilia, no identity
Autogynephilia is a paraphilia: sexual arousal at the thought of oneself as a woman. Not an inner identity — a sexual pattern.
US rollout: WPATH, clinics, and federal policy
The US rollout of transgender care: Boston Children, Planned Parenthood, federal guidelines under Biden, rollback under Trump-2.