GenderID.nl

A belief · not a fact · critically examined

Home › Research › Desistance

Desistance: 60-90% of children lose dysphoria spontaneously

The most stable empirical data regarding childhood gender dysphoria is erased, distorted, or dismissed as outdated by the affirmative lobby: the vast majority of children with gender dysphoria lose it during puberty. They usually become homosexual adults. Treating them with puberty blockers is not a concern — it is the sterilization of homosexual children under an ideological label.

What desistance is

Desistance — the spontaneous disappearance of gender dysphoria in adolescence without medical intervention. The term comes from clinical literature and is supported by ten follow-up studies from the Netherlands, Canada, the UK, and the US. It is not a marginal finding; it was a consensus until precisely the moment that WPATH affirmation became politically desirable.

The figures

  • Zucker (2008) — 87.8% desistance in Toronto cohort.
  • Steensma (2011, 2013) — 84% desistance in Amsterdam cohort.
  • Wallien & Cohen-Kettenis (2008) — 73% desistance.
  • Drummond (2008) — 88% desistance in girl cohort.
  • Singh (2021) — again 87.8% desistance.

Aggregation of studies: 60 to 90 percent. Ten to thirty percent persist into adolescence or adulthood. Not a single follow-up study finds percentages that support the affirmative "born trans" doctrine.

What most desisters become

In the cohort studies, approximately 60 to 80 percent of the desisters became homosexual or bisexual as adults. Conclusion: in a large proportion of cases, "childhood gender dysphoria" expresses an early development of homosexuality — not an innate "transidentity." Social and medical affirmation of such a child directly interferes with normal homosexual development. Anyone who prescribes blockers to a dysphoric ten-year-old girl is, statistically speaking, treating a future lesbian to infertility. No minor detail; an ethical scandal.

The activist objection analyzed

Activists claim that desistance figures are outdated or mixed with "only gender-deviant behavior." Incorrect: Zucker and Steensma used DSM criteria for gender identity disorder. Recent "affirmative" literature employs vaguer definitions—and is subsequently used to disqualify older, sharper data. It is a rhetorical trick, not a methodological argument. The pattern repeats itself with ROGD research , with detransition figures , and with the Zhou debunk : unwanted data are silenced, not refuted.

Social transition closes the exit

A child who undergoes social transition, receives blockers, and subsequently hormones, embarks on a virtually inevitable path. Steensma's own research shows that social transition significantly increases the likelihood of persistence — it is not a neutral "exploration" but a diagnostic decision with irreversible consequences. The Cass Review , SBU Sweden , COHERE Finland , and the NICE review acknowledge this; Dutch gender care ignores it, despite Steensma being Dutch. See also the criticism of the Dutch Protocol .

What this means

Statistically speaking, early medical intervention is not a treatment for trans children — it is iatrogenic harm to children who would die spontaneously in 60-90% of cases. Transition does not cure; it confirms a diagnosis that, in most cases, need not have persisted. The closure of Tavistock came about partly due to the recognition of precisely these data.

Sources

  1. Zucker, K. (2008). Children with gender identity disorder. Journal of Sex Research .
  2. Steensma, T. et al. (2013). Factors associated with desistence and persistence of childhood gender dysphoria. JAACAP .
  3. Singh, D. et al. (2021). A follow-up study of boys with gender identity disorder. Frontiers in Psychiatry . frontiersin.org

See also