GenderID.nl

A belief · not a fact · critically examined

Home › Identities › Non-binary

Non-binary

"Non-binary" is a label for people who do not identify exclusively as male or female. Critics point out that the definition is open and rests on self-report alone; supporters see non-binary as an identity in its own right.

Definition according to proponents

WPATH SOC8 describes nonbinary as an umbrella term for people whose gender identity falls outside the categories of man and woman (source). The definition is open: in between, both, neither, fluctuating or something else.

Origin and spread

Related terms circulated in queer theory from the 1990s (see Judith Butler). According to the Cass Review, non-binary is the fastest-growing group under the trans umbrella, and even less is known about the outcomes for this group (source). See also the spread since 2010 and Littman/ROGD.

Criticism: a negation as identity

Critics note that "non-binary" mainly says what someone is not — neither man nor woman — rather than what someone is. There is no measurable marker that tests the claim; only self-report. See also circular reasoning and unfalsifiability.

Kathleen Stock (Material Girls, 2021) criticises the theory that gender identity should weigh more heavily in society than biological sex. Levine, Abbruzzese and Mason (2022) discuss the problems of informed consent for trans-identified children, adolescents and young adults.

What the sources say about treatment

The Cass Review (2024) writes that only three guidelines address the treatment of non-binary young people: the Swedish and Norwegian ones do not recommend hormone treatment for this group because of a lack of evidence, whereas WPATH does recommend tailored hormone treatment, in a separate chapter on non-binary people, so it is unclear whether this applies to adolescents (source). SBU (2022) found the evidence insufficient to assess the effects of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones (source). See also detransition research.

Related identities

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources

  1. Aitken, M. et al. (2015). Evidence for an altered sex ratio in clinic-referred adolescents with gender dysphoria. Journal of Sexual Medicine .
  2. Cass, H. (2024). Final Report . cass.independent-review.uk .
  3. Littman, L. (2018). Rapid-onset gender dysphoria. PLOS ONE , 13(8).
  4. Stock, K. (2021). Material Girls . Fleet.
  5. Joyce, H. (2021). Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality . Oneworld.

See also