Home › Criticism › Denial of reality

Denial of reality: self-appointment has limits

People are allowed to label themselves in many ways — but not everything that is self-labeled is necessarily true. Otherkin, transabled, trans-racial, and age-transition show that "I feel it, therefore I am it" cannot be a criterion. Gender identity is exactly the same structure — but with legal coercion behind it.

The fundamental distinction

Self-identification is legitimate where it does not make a factual claim that binds others: "I am Catholic", "I am a vegetarian", "I am an artist". Self-identification becomes problematic when it (1) makes factual claims about biology or history, (2) imposes rights or obligations on others, (3) makes verification impossible by appealing to an inner feeling. Gender identity claims do all three — and require society to play along on pain of exclusion as a hater.

Reductio: the cases that are rejected

A 50-year-old white man who identifies as a 12-year-old Asian girl is not legally recognized — rightly so. A man who identifies as a doctor is not treated as a doctor without qualification. Otherkin (people who identify as a wolf, dragon, or elf), transabled (people who identify as disabled and want healthy limbs amputated), and transage are all treated as delusions or disorders. The logical structure of those claims is identical to transgender — only the political winds are blowing differently.

The trans-racial parallel

Rachel Dolezal identified as Black; her claim was publicly dismissed as deception. Philosopher Rebecca Tuvel ( Hypatia , 2017) showed that the logical structure is identical to that of transgender. The letter from hundreds of academics calling for Tuvel's article to be retracted proved her point: the difference rests not on argument, but on political force. See also feminist criticism .

The compassion trap

Compassion is often invoked against criticism: "these people are suffering, grant them their identity." However, compassion requires honesty, not agreement with falsehood. It is not compassion to affirm someone with anorexia in "I am too fat"; nor to aid amputation in someone with body integrity dysphoria. True care demands truth. See being versus feeling and circular reasoning .

The damage of pushing away reality

On this "I feel, therefore I am" rest puberty blockers in children who cannot see eye to eye, mastectomies on healthy girls, legal self-ID without any assessment, and the breaking open of women's spaces, sports, and shelters. Detransitioners bear the irreversible damage — transition does not heal. Anyone who raises the issue is silenced.